Prayer [Salat]
Is The Prayer Of The One Who Shaves His Beard Fulfilled?
إنما خص الصلاۃ بالذكَّأنہا أفضل عبادات البدن، فإذا لم یقبل منہا فلأن لا یقبل منہا عبادۃ أصلا کان أولی، قال المظہر: ہذا وأمثالہ مبنی علی الزجر وألا یسقط عنہ فرض الصلاۃ إذا أداہا بشرائطہا ولکن لیس ثواب صلاۃ الفاسق کثواب صلاۃ الصالح، بل الفسق ینفی کمال الصلاۃ وغیرہا من الطاعات، وقال النووی إن لكل طاعۃ اعتبارین : أحدہما سقوط القضاء عن المؤدی، وثانیہما ترتیب حصول الثواب فعبر عن عدم ترتیب الثواب بعدم قبول الصلاۃ
مرقاۃ المفاتیح شرح مشکوۃ المصابیح، ۷ /۳۲۱:کتاب الحدود،باب بیان الخمرووعیدشاربھا
Prayer is a specific form of mediation [dhikr] because it is superior among physical worship. So if this is not fulfilled, no other first-hand worship will be fulfilled. These and other similar examples are based on this warning. However, the obligation [fard] of the prayer will be fulfilled if it is performed under its terms. But the reward of the transgressor’s prayer will not be the same as the prayer of the pious. The completeness of the transgressor’s prayer and his other worship is rather negative. Imam al-Nawawi said that worship has two aspects, one of which is the release of the obligation in fulfilling it and the other is the settlement of receiving the reward. So the prayer that is not fulfilled is understood as having no settlement of the reward.”
مراقی الفلاح شرح نورالایضاح:کتاب الصلاۃ،ص ۱۲۴
ج۱/۱۰۹،کتاب الصلاۃ،باب مایفسدالصلاۃ ومایکرہ فیھا
But he has already shaved his beard, how will he pray soundly the second time? However, it is different if he repents for shaving his beard. In short, in the afterlife, he would also be held accountable after praying as such, if he did not repeat properly. Yes, his punishment will be less than the punishment for neglecting prayer.
19-Rabi al-Thani-1437 || ≈ 29-Jan-2016
al-Fuyudat al-Nabawiyyah fi’l-Fatawa al-Hanafiyya (Fatawa Uttarakhand): vol. 2, p. 173, #27
Click for more fatawa’s of Mufti Zulfaqar Naimi